Compellingly Written History | Twelve Days: The Story of the 1956 Hungarian Revolution (Vintage)

Very good book. | Twelve Days: The Story of the 1956 Hungarian Revolution (Vintage) | Victor Sebestyen

books:


	• Twelve Days: The Story of the 1956 Hungarian Revolution (Vintage) Victor Sebestyen Vintage, 2007 - 384 pages average customer review:based on 17 reviews view larger image
	for more information click here

highly recommended

Great Men History more than the little man's perspective

I agree with previous reviewers who went beyond an emotional summary of the Revolution or comments on the structure of Sebestyen's history to comment on particular strengths and weaknesses of his study. Brandon Wilkenning accurately critiqued the book's concentration upon an elite-centered cadre. The results in "Twelve Days" reminded me more of an old-fashioned account reliant more upon diplomatic manuevers, archival correspondence, and Cold War contexts than one based on internal political analyses, first-hand testimonies from street fighters, or eyewitness journalists. These all are included, admittedly, but the flavor of the book remains rather bland as Sebestyen prefers situating the 1956 uprising in the greater framework of Soviet-U.S. relations. This is not to the book's detriment per se, but it did vitiate its energy for me as a curious reader familiar with events reported by other writers from Budapest and Hungary at this time. I'd been hoping for a livelier narrative. The material often fascinates despite the plodding prose.

However, Sebestyen granted his focus gives us an Imre Nagy who continued to lag a day behind, until he was trapped by the lies of Yuri Andropov. Pól Maléter emerges as more of a "national communist" than others he fought with, and Sebestyen glances over a crucial problem in how we define the goals of those who bravely fought the Soviets and their allies in the Hungarian CP. Maléter argues for an anti-capitalist revolt (p. 187); Sebestyen refers (pp. 195, 221) to how as the revolt continued that anti-communist industrial workers (usually under thirty, usually tradesmen) from strongholds like Csepel island gained the upper hand over intellectuals and students who may have begun the rebellion. These mentions constitute the summation of his treatment of this important topic. Since many in the West spin-doctored 1956 as an anti-Marxist liberation front, and since others who have discussed the revolt have taken pains to insist upon its "democratic socialist" intentions (although that ideological phrase is not as I recall used by Sebestyen), I remain less enlightened than I'd hoped when I started "Twelve Days."

The book's likely by default, as it's timed to the fiftieth anniversary in its publication and promotion, to become a standard introduction. The maps are useful, and you can appreciate what Sebestyen tells you about the strategic importance of the Kilián Barracks and the Corvin Cinema. The AVO's role and the fate of those lynched earns explanation that had often been clouded in earlier studies. The cynicism of Stalinist Hungary and the Muscovites who returned from the purges to collaborate gains needed scrutiny. The jails in which in the early 1950s held 1.3 million of 9 million citizens merit description. The relentlessly transient definition of truth in a land of fear, betrayal, lies, and inhumanity appears much more vivid after close attention to early pages of the book.

Eisenhower, Nixon, Dulles, Khrushchev, Kádár, and Rákosi emerge better understood for the calculating decisions they made. The UN won no plaudits, nor Hammerskjold. Cardinal Mindszenty became for me stubborn, enigmatic, and unsympathetic. Radio Free Europe and the CIA both earn in Sebestyen's unearthing of primary sources more culpability than certain previous scholars have attributed to them for goading the fighters on, both before and during the revolution.

Yet, it could have been better in its details. Its bibliography gives earlier English-language works, but a few published memoirs which I have read are not included. Near the end, on p. 287, he recounts the terrible fate of Mária Wittner, who I wondered may have been one of the "freedom fighters" in a well-known photo of two young women walking along, fully-armed, early in the uprising. Yet, this photo's not included in what's a rather skimpy array of illustrations on what by now is an historical event that earned many pictorial moments deserving a place in this book. Above all, you still close this book with too little a feel for what it was like to fight, flee, hide, or endure the revolt. The post-revolt sufferings of those arrested get treated too superficially, the fate of those released who had to survive in Kádár's regime stays rather hazy, and what kind of post-Soviet 1956 Hungary that those who fought in the streets wanted remains vague.

How much of this is the fault of the book and how much is due to the understandable uncertainty of life in wartime leaves you as a reader pondering this intriguing subject. On the other hand, perhaps Hungarians simply were too busy, as Sebestyen notes, endlessly talking in the brief euphoria after the illusory withdrawal of the armed Russian bears to have time to plan. Sebestyen waffles on the political substance of the brief republic proclaimed. I remain baffled. Yet, perhaps many people themselves once free wished first to dream, exult, and babble. "A study among refugees later suggested that on average people made between 300 and 400 calls in thirteen days." (184) The governing plans made by the mimeographing proclaimers and exuberant rebels in passing here seem to be multifarious. A thousand flowers bloomed amidst the broken glass and towering rubble, a few hours between October and November, 1956.

for more information click here

Compellingly Written History

Alexis de Toqueville said the most dangerous moment for an autocratic government is when it tries to reform itself. The revolts against Soviet rule in Hungary in 1956 and in Czechoslovakia in 1968 are cases in point. Here, Hungarian-British journalist Sebastyen (whose family fled Hungary in the wake of the 1956 uprising) offers a limpidly written, meticulously researched page-turner recounting Hungary's revolt against the USSR after nearly a decade of the oppressive Stalinist rule of Matyas Rakosi. The Hungarian Revolution, sparked by student revolts, took place against the backdrop of Nikita Khrushchev's "secret" denunciation of Stalin and his attempts to liberalize Soviet rule. The uprising exposed both the fragility of the Communist regime and the hollow nature of U.S. anti-Communist rhetoric, which vainly encouraged the rebels to think American support would be forthcoming. Sebastyen's grim narrative does not shy away from recounting the intense violence of the revolt and its brutal suppression, and conveys the sense of tragic foreboding that must have been felt by reluctant leader Imre Nagy and other revolutionaries even as they celebrated their brief taste of freedom. Sebastyen's work has a compelling "you are there" immediacy throughout. Excellent, if somewhat depressing when one contemplates the enormous waste of human lives that Stalin's megalomaniacal, paranoiac rule entailed both for the USSR and its European satrapies.

for more information click here

Very good book.

This book paints a vivid picture of Budapest during the Soviet occupation of Hungary. It's a very good book.

for more information click here

classic history of Hungarian uprising of 1956

This is probably the best history of the 1956 Hungarian uprising against the Soviets. The book was written after the Soviet Union collapsed and the Russian government release material from the Soviet Archives. So the reader gets the story both from the point of view of the Hungarian patiots and the Politburo in Moscow. A tale of great courage and great savagery. Sebestyen is a marvelously lucid writer. Must read for anyone interested in the history of the Cold War.

for more information click here

To a revolution

After many books published by refugees in the sixties, the Hungarian Revolution against the Soviets in 1956 went largely unexamined for fifty years. Except for Michener's Bridge at Andau, still the most passionate yet journalistic account of those events, most titles went out of print. With the 50th anniversary of the revolt just behind us, Sebestyen's book is a welcome reawakening of those two weeks when a small country rose up against a larger, only to end with the sad SOS from Budapest heard by the rest of the world but ignored. New documentation available since the fall of the Soviet Union makes this book worthwhile both intellectually and emotionally. Soul of Flesh: A Novel of the 1956 Hungarian Revolution

for more information click here

Twelve Days is a riveting day-by-day account of the defining moment of the Cold War?the inspiring but brutally crushed Hungarian Uprising.

Victor Sebestyen, a journalist whose own family fled Hungary, gives us a totally fresh account, incorporating newly released official documents, his family's diaries, and eyewitness testimony. We witness the thrilling first days when?armed only with a few rifles, petrol bombs, and desperate courage?the people of Budapest rose up against their Soviet masters and nearly succeeded. As the world watched in amazement, it looked as though the Hungarians might humble the Soviet empire. But the Soviets were willing to resort to brutal lengths?and, sadly, the West was prepared to let them. Dramatic, vivid, and authoritative, Twelve Days adds immeasurably to our understanding of this historic event and reminds us of the unquenchable human desire for freedom.

for more information click here

reviews: page 1, 2, 3, 4

hot